Green Key Lime Pie

The bright electric slice that made my brotherinlaw actually pause midconversation at our summer potluck. He is a dessert skeptic but that first tangy creamy bite had him asking for seconds before his fork even hit the plate.

I started making key lime pie after a trip to Florida where I learned that authentic key limes are tiny and their juice has this distinct floral brightness you just cannot get from regular limes. Now I keep a stash of bottled key lime juice in the pantry year round so I can whip up this sunshine anytime someone needs a pick me up.

Ingredients

• Graham cracker crumbs: These create the classic crunchy buttery base that holds up beautifully against the soft custard filling and I always pulse them in the food processor for the finest most even texture
• Sweetened condensed milk: This is the secret to that silky smooth texture and it provides just the right amount of sweetness to balance the intense lime flavor
• Egg yolks: Only the yolks are needed here as they provide richness and help the filling set properly without becoming rubbery or dense
• Key lime juice: Fresh is fantastic but do not stress about using bottled key lime juice which is perfectly acceptable and often more consistent than trying to juice dozens of tiny key limes
• Green food coloring: The color is completely optional but I love how it makes the pie look as vibrant as it tastes and guests always comment on the striking appearance
• Heavy whipping cream: Lightly sweetened homemade whipped cream puts any store bought topping to shame and it comes together in just a few minutes with an electric mixer

Instructions

Preheat and prepare the crust:

Press the buttery graham cracker mixture firmly into your pie dish using the bottom of a measuring cup to create an even compact layer that will hold together when sliced.

Bake the crust:

Give it just 8 minutes in the oven to set the structure and create those wonderfully toasted graham notes that pair so beautifully with the bright citrus.

Whisk the filling:

Beat the condensed milk and egg yolks until completely smooth then add that lime juice slowly as it will begin to thicken immediately from the acid reacting with the milk proteins.

Add color and zest:

Stir in the lime zest and a few drops of green food coloring until you reach that signature vibrant hue that makes this pie so fun to serve.

Bake briefly:

The filling only needs about 7 minutes in the oven just enough to set the structure while keeping that luscious creamy custard texture.

Chill thoroughly:

Let the pie cool completely at room temperature then refrigerate for at least 4 hours or even better overnight for the cleanest most professional slices.

Make the topping:

Whip the heavy cream with powdered sugar and vanilla until it holds soft peaks then either spread it generously or pipe it in beautiful rosettes over the cold pie.

Garnish and serve:

Add fresh lime zest or thin lime wheels on top for that final pop of color and a hint of what is waiting inside each slice.

Save to Pinterest

This pie became our go to celebration dessert after my sister requested it for her graduation instead of a fancy cake. She said the combination of cool creamy filling and crisp buttery crust reminded her of carefree summer days and sometimes simple memories taste better than anything else.

Making It Naturally Green

If you prefer to avoid artificial food coloring try blending a handful of fresh baby spinach with the lime juice then straining it through a fine mesh sieve. The result is a lovely soft green that looks completely natural and you cannot taste the spinach at all.

Getting The Perfect Crust

I learned to press the crust mixture up the sides of the pie dish first then focus on the bottom to prevent those dreaded thin spots where the filling can seep through. The measuring cup technique creates a beautifully compact crust that slices cleanly every time.

Storage And Serving

This pie keeps remarkably well in the refrigerator for up to three days though the crust may soften slightly over time. Serve it well chilled but not fridge cold so the flavors have a chance to really shine on your palate.

• Add the whipped cream topping just before serving as it can weep and become watery if it sits on the pie too long
• Run your knife under hot water and wipe it clean between slices for those picture perfect restaurant style pieces
• The pie actually develops a deeper more complex lime flavor after sitting overnight so do not be afraid to make it a day ahead

Save to Pinterest

Every time I serve this vivid green pie someone inevitably asks about the secret ingredient and I just smile knowing sometimes the most memorable desserts are also the simplest to make.

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of crust is used here?

A graham cracker crust, made with crumbs, sugar, and melted butter, baked until firm and crisp.

→ How is the filling naturally colored green?

Green food coloring can be added, or fresh spinach blended with lime juice for a natural green hue.

→ Can fresh lime juice be substituted?

Yes, bottled key lime juice works well and provides consistent tartness.

→ How long should the pie chill before serving?

At least 4 hours in the refrigerator to ensure the filling is fully set and flavors meld.

→ What is the purpose of the whipped cream topping?

It adds a light, creamy contrast to the tangy filling and enhances texture and flavor balance.

→ How can the crust be made crispier?

Bake the crust 2–3 minutes longer before adding the filling for extra crunch.